Why Body Positivity Can Be Harmful

The Origins of Body Positivity

Body positivity began as a movement that aimed to empower individuals to embrace their bodies, regardless of societal beauty standards. It was a response to the unrealistic and often harmful expectations placed upon individuals to conform to a certain body type or size. The movement advocated for the appreciation and acceptance of different body shapes, sizes, and skin colors, encouraging people to love themselves as they are.

The Good Intentions of Body Positivity

Body positivity started with good intentions. It aimed to help those who had been negatively affected by unrealistic beauty standards and encourage them to embrace their bodies. The movement made strides in promoting self-love and acceptance, as well as combating fatphobia and body shaming.

The Problem with Body Positivity

While body positivity started with good intentions, it has evolved into something that can be harmful to some individuals. The movement has become co-opted by diet culture and fitness influencers, which has resulted in the promotion of a narrow definition of beauty that is not inclusive of all body types.

The Unhealthy Side of Body Positivity

The current iteration of body positivity has created a culture of “good” and “bad” bodies, which can be damaging to people’s mental health. It has resulted in the demonization of certain body types, such as thin bodies, and the glorification of others, such as curvy bodies. This has led to the creation of a new set of beauty standards that can be just as harmful as the old ones.

The Negative Effects of Body Positivity

Body Shaming in Disguise

Body positivity has resulted in the promotion of a “healthy” body image. However, this definition of health is often tied to a certain body type, one that is not inclusive of all bodies. This has resulted in the stigmatization and shaming of individuals who do not conform to this ideal body type.

The Reinforcement of Beauty Standards

Body positivity has led to the creation of a new set of beauty standards that can be just as harmful as the old ones. It has resulted in the glorification of certain body types, which can create feelings of inadequacy in individuals who do not conform to these standards.

The Harmful Side of Diet Culture

Body positivity has been co-opted by diet culture, which has resulted in the promotion of weight loss and restrictive diets as a means of achieving a “healthy” body. This has resulted in the demonization of certain foods and the promotion of unhealthy eating behaviors.

A Better Alternative

Intuitive Eating

Intuitive eating is an alternative to dieting that focuses on listening to your body’s cues and eating in a way that feels good to you. It promotes a healthy relationship with food and rejects the idea that certain foods are “good” or “bad.”

Health at Every Size

Health at Every Size (HAES) is a movement that promotes the idea that health is not tied to a certain body type or weight. It encourages individuals to focus on healthy behaviors, such as eating nutritious foods and exercising, rather than on achieving a certain body type.

Self-Love and Acceptance

Self-love and acceptance are key components of body positivity. However, they should not be tied to a certain body type or size. Instead, they should be promoted as a way of embracing all bodies and encouraging individuals to love themselves as they are.

Conclusion

While body positivity started with good intentions, it has evolved into something that can be harmful to some individuals. The movement has become co-opted by diet culture and fitness influencers, resulting in the promotion of a narrow definition of beauty that is not inclusive of all body types. Instead of promoting a certain body type as “healthy,” we should focus on promoting healthy behaviors and encouraging individuals to love themselves as they are.